Consider the following statements:
P:I have feverQ:I will not take medicineR:I will take rest.
The statement "If I have fever, then I will take medicine and I will take rest" is equivalent to:
Your answer stays private
What feels right?
Hint 1 of 3
What is the symbolic representation of the statement: 'If I have fever, then I will take medicine and I will take rest'?
No score. Commit to your first instinct. We’ll show what your mind noticed and what it missed.
Step-by-step solutionView
Correct answer
The given statement translates to P→(∼Q∧R), which is logically equivalent to ((∼P)∨∼Q)∧((∼P)∨R).
Option analysis
Why each option works or fails
A · ((∼P)∨∼Q)∧((∼P)∨R)
None. This option correctly translates the given compound statement into propositional logic and applies standard equivalence laws. Recognize that 'I will take medicine' is ∼Q, making the statement P→(∼Q∧R), which expands to (∼P∨∼Q)∧(∼P∨R).
B · (P∨Q)∧((∼P)∨R)
The student failed to negate P in the first disjunct, mistakenly writing P∨Q instead of ∼P∨∼Q, and ignored the negation on Q. Remember that the conditional law converts A→B to ∼A∨B; the antecedent must always be negated.
C · ((∼P)∨∼Q)∧((∼P)∨∼R)
The student erroneously negated R when distributing the disjunction over the conjunction. Keep the truth values of the consequent components intact: 'I will take rest' is R, not ∼R.
D · (P∨∼Q)∧(P∨∼R)
The student confused the conditional equivalence with its converse or contrapositive form, failing to negate the antecedent P and mistakenly negating R. Apply the rule P→X≡∼P∨X, rather than P∨∼X.
Reviewed route
Solution
StepWorking
01given
Given the primitive statements:
P:I have feverQ:I will not take medicineR:I will take rest.
02goal
Find a logically equivalent symbolic statement for: "If I have fever, then I will take medicine and I will take rest".
03approach
Translate the verbal statement into propositional logic:
- "I have fever" is P.
- "I will take medicine" is the negation of Q, i.e., ∼Q.
- "I will take rest" is R.
Thus, the compound statement is P→(∼Q∧R). Then rewrite the implication using A→B≡∼A∨B and apply the distributive law.
04execute
1. Express the implication as a disjunction:
P→(∼Q∧R)≡(∼P)∨(∼Q∧R)
2. Distribute ∨ over ∧:
(∼P)∨(∼Q∧R)≡((∼P)∨∼Q)∧((∼P)∨R)
✓verify
Check truth value when P is False (F): P→… is vacuously True (T). In the derived expression, if P=F, then ∼P=T, making both ((∼P)∨∼Q) and ((∼P)∨R) True, so their conjunction is True. This matches Option (0).
Hints that build this answer step by step
What is the symbolic representation of the statement: 'If I have fever, then I will take medicine and I will take rest'?
P→(∼Q∧R)
Using the conditional equivalence A→B≡∼A∨B, how is P→(∼Q∧R) rewritten?
∼P∨(∼Q∧R)
Applying the distributive law A∨(B∧C)≡(A∨B)∧(A∨C) to ∼P∨(∼Q∧R), what is the resulting expression?