Organic Compounds Containing Oxygen: Chemistry | JEE Main
The descending order of acidity for the following carboxylic acid is :
A. CH3COOH
B. F3C−COOH
C. ClCH2−COOH
D. FCH2−COOH
E. BrCH2−COOH
Choose the correct answer from the options given below :
Your answer stays private
What feels right?
Hint 1 of 2
What primary electronic effect determines the relative acidity of halo-substituted carboxylic acids?
No score. Commit to your first instinct. We’ll show what your mind noticed and what it missed.
Step-by-step solutionView
Correct answer
Electron-withdrawing groups (−I effect) stabilize the carboxylate anion, giving the acidity order: CF3COOH>FCH2COOH>ClCH2COOH>BrCH2COOH>CH3COOH (i.e., B>D>C>E>A).
Option analysis
Why each option works or fails
A · D>B>A>E>C
Believing that monosubstituted haloacids are stronger than tri-substituted ones and confusing the order of inductive stabilization. Three electron-withdrawing fluorines exert a vastly stronger cumulative −I effect than a single fluorine, making CF3COOH (B) the most acidic.
B · E>D>B>A>C
Assuming that acidity increases down the halogen group rather than tracking electronegativity, placing bromine higher than fluorine. The −I effect increases with increasing electronegativity of the halogen (F>Cl>Br), so fluorinated acids are more acidic than brominated acids.
C · B>C>D>E>A
Incorrectly ordering chlorine as more electronegative than fluorine, ranking ClCH2COOH ahead of FCH2COOH. Fluorine is more electronegative than chlorine, so FCH2COOH (D) stabilizes the conjugate base more strongly via inductive effect than ClCH2COOH (C).
D · B>D>C>E>A
None. This is the correct descending order of carboxylic acid acidity. Rank by number of electron-withdrawing groups first (CF3 > CH2X), then by electronegativity of halogen (F>Cl>Br), with unsubstituted CH3COOH being the least acidic.
Reviewed route
Solution
StepWorking
01concept
Acidity of carboxylic acids depends on the stability of the carboxylate conjugate base.
Electron-withdrawing groups (-I effect) disperse the negative charge. This stabilizes the carboxylate anion and increases acidity.
The -I strength of halogens follows electronegativity: −F>−Cl>−Br.
The number of electron-withdrawing groups also magnifies the effect. Three fluorines (\-CF3) exert a much stronger -I effect than a single fluorine (\-CH2F).
Unsubstituted acetic acid (\-CH3) has an electron-donating (+I) alkyl group. This makes it the least acidic.
02option_verdict
Places D (\-CH2F) before B (\-CF3), ignoring the cumulative magnitude of three -I groups.
03option_verdict
Places E (bromoacetic acid) as the strongest acid, completely inverting the halogen electronegativity trend.
04option_verdict
Places C (\-Cl) ahead of D (\-F), contradicting the electronegativity order F>Cl.
Identify the extreme ends first: CF3COOH (B) must be the strongest and CH3COOH (A) must be the weakest, eliminating options 0 and 1 immediately. Then between B > D vs B > C, fluorine is more electronegative than chlorine, locking B > D > C > E > A.
Hints that build this answer step by step
What primary electronic effect determines the relative acidity of halo-substituted carboxylic acids?
The inductive electron-withdrawing effect (−I), which disperses negative charge in the conjugate base.
How does the number and electronegativity of the halogen substituents rank the acids from most acidic to least acidic?
Why does trifluoroacetic acid have a higher acidity than fluoroacetic acid?
Inductive effects are additive. Three electronegative fluorine atoms pull electron density much more strongly than a single fluorine atom, greatly stabilizing the conjugate base.