Ordering substituted phenols by
What feels right?
How does acid strength correlate with values?
No score. Commit to your first instinct. We’ll show what your mind noticed and what it missed.
How does acid strength correlate with values?
No score. Commit to your first instinct. We’ll show what your mind noticed and what it missed.
Correct answer
Option analysis
This is the correct order. Electron-withdrawing groups increase acidity (lower ), while electron-donating groups decrease acidity (raise ). Ranking from strongest acid to weakest acid yields (A) < (B) < (E) < (D) < (C).
Confusing acid strength () with , ranking from weakest acid to strongest acid instead of lowest to highest . Remember that ; a stronger acid has a smaller (more negative) value.
Believing inductive electron withdrawal from meta-chloro is stronger than the combined resonance and inductive electron withdrawal of para-nitro. A para- group stabilizes the phenoxide ion through strong and effects, making 4-nitrophenol significantly more acidic than 3-chlorophenol (which only has a effect).
Reversing the relation between acidity and while simultaneously misplacing meta-chloro relative to unsubstituted phenol. Electron-withdrawing groups like chlorine increase acidity and lower relative to unsubstituted phenol, and increasing means ordering from strongest acid to weakest acid.
Acidic strength of substituted phenols is enhanced by electron-withdrawing groups () which stabilize the phenoxide anion, and decreased by electron-donating groups () which destabilize it. Since , a stronger acid has a lower . Therefore, the increasing order of corresponds directly to the decreasing order of acidic strength (from strongest acid to weakest acid).
(A) 2,4-Dinitrophenol has two strong and nitro groups strongest acid lowest . (B) 4-Nitrophenol has one group second strongest acid. (E) 3-Chlorophenol has meta-Cl exerting only effect moderately acidic. (D) Phenol is unsubstituted. (C) 2,4,5-Trimethylphenol has three methyl groups destabilizing the phenoxide weakest acid highest . Thus, increasing order of is (A) < (B) < (E) < (D) < (C).
This ranks the compounds in increasing order of acidic strength (or decreasing order of ), confusing high acidity with high .
Places (E) 3-chlorophenol as more acidic than (B) 4-nitrophenol, mistakenly overestimating the effect of chlorine relative to the resonance electron-withdrawing () effect of the para-nitro group.
Inverts the relationship and also misplaces 3-chlorophenol relative to phenol.
The strongest acid (2,4-dinitrophenol, A) must have the lowest , eliminating Options 1 and 3 immediately. Since 4-nitrophenol (B) has strong stabilization while 3-chlorophenol (E) only has weak , B is more acidic than E, meaning , picking Option 0.
How does acid strength correlate with values?
Stronger acids have lower values, so increasing means ordering from strongest acid to weakest acid.How do the substituents on these phenols affect acid strength via electronic effects?
Two groups > one group > meta- > > three groups in stabilizing the conjugate base.Combining the acidity order (A > B > E > D > C) with the inverse relation to , what is the increasing order of ?
(A) < (B) < (E) < (D) < (C)Quick checks
Because pKa is defined as -log10(Ka). A higher Ka means a stronger acid, which yields a more negative/smaller pKa value.