Gravitation: JEE Main Physics Question with Solution
A planet has double the mass of the earth. Its average density is equal to the that of the earth. An object weighing W on earth will weigh on that planet :
Your answer stays private
What feels right?
No score. Commit to your first instinct. We’ll show what your mind noticed and what it missed.
Step-by-step solutionView
Correct answer
Because mass scales with the cube of the radius for constant density, doubling the mass increases the radius by a factor of 21/3, which leads to a weight of 21/3 W.
Option analysis
Why each option works or fails
A · 22/3 W
Inverting the power relationship when substituting R∝M1/3 into g=GM/R2, arriving at M/M1/3=M2/3 instead of M/M2/3=M1/3. Compute g∝M/(M1/3)2=M/M2/3=M1−2/3=M1/3 carefully.
B · W
Believing that having the same density means the surface gravity remains completely unchanged regardless of total mass. Surface gravity depends on radius as well as density (g=34πGρR); since mass doubled at constant density, radius must increase, altering surface gravity.
C · 21/3 W
Correct option. Since M=34πR3ρ, R∝M1/3. Therefore, g=34πGρR∝M1/3, yielding W′=21/3W.
D · 2 W
Assuming weight is directly proportional to mass alone (W∝M) without accounting for the increased planetary radius that reduces the surface gravitational field. Remember that surface gravity depends on radius via g=GM/R2; a larger mass at constant density occupies a larger volume and thus has a larger radius.
Reviewed route
Solution
StepWorking
01given
M′=2M, ρ′=ρ, Weight on Earth =W=mg=mR2GM.
02find
Find the weight W′ of the object on the new planet.
03visualise
A spherical planet with mass M=34πR3ρ. For constant density ρ, radius scales with mass as R∝M1/3.
04strategise
Express surface gravity g=R2GM purely in terms of M by substituting R∝M1/3, yielding g∝(M1/3)2M=M1/3. Then weight W∝g∝M1/3.
05execute
Since M′=2M, the new weight is W′=W(MM′)1/3=21/3W.
✓verify
Double mass at constant density means larger volume and larger radius (R′=21/3R). Surface gravity increases by a factor of 2/(21/3)2=21/3, so W′=21/3W, which is physically consistent.
Why does R change if only mass is explicitly doubled?
Because density ρ=34πR3M is given as constant. If mass doubles and density is unchanged, volume must double, which forces R to increase by a factor of 21/3.